• Home
  • About Mark Skousen
    • Catalog
    • Mark Skousen Biography
    • Commonly Asked Questions
    • Jo Ann Skousen Biography
    • Mark Skousen’s Family and Famous Relatives
    • Books Recommended by Mark Skousen
    • Personal and Miscellaneous
  • Books
    • Economics Books
      • Economic Logic
      • EconoPower: How a New Generation of Economists Is Transforming the World
      • The Big Three in Economics: Adam Smith, Karl Marx and John Maynard Keynes
      • The Making of Modern Economics
      • The Structure of Production
      • Vienna & Chicago, Friends or Foes?
    • Finance and Investing Books
      • Maxims of Wall Street
      • A Viennese Waltz Down Wall Street: Austrian Economics for Investors
      • Investing In One Lesson
      • High Finance on a Low Budget
      • The New Scrooge Investing
  • Interviews
  • Appearances
  • Online Press Kit
    • Contact Information
    • Biographical Information
    • Headshots
    • List of Current Books
    • Forecasts & Strategies, Trading Services and Weekly Blog
  • FreedomFest
  • Persuasion vs. Force

MSKOUSEN.COM

Mark Skousen's Personal Website for the Best of Money & Economics

  • News
  • Economics
  • Personal Finance
  • Investing & Markets
  • Forecasts & Strategies
  • Politics & Liberty

TEXTBOOKS TAKE FREE-MARKET TACK But Many Welfare-State Myths Still Are Taught

October 22, 1998 By Mark Skousen Leave a Comment

NATIONAL ISSUE — Investor’s Business Daily

TEXTBOOKS TAKE FREE-MARKET TACK But Many Welfare-State Myths Still Are Taught

Date: 10/22/98
Author: Michael Chapman


Many students today learn a lot about free-market economics. Problem is, John Maynard Keynes, the godfather of the welfare state, is doing the teaching.

Still, in recent years, textbooks have improved. Free-market economists like Milton Friedman and Friedrich Hayek get some play. But their successful ideas still aren’t getting the coverage they deserve.

The problem is what’s not taught, the ”sins of omission,” said economist Mark Skousen, author of ”Economics on Trial: Lies, Myths, and Realities.”

”I give the textbooks higher marks now,” he said, ”but there’s still much more to do.”

Free enterprise and private property are what America was built on. The idea of private property – ”life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” – is enshrined in the Declaration of Independence.

Economic freedom is essential to political freedom, says Nobel Prize winner Friedman.

In countries with little economic freedom, such as China or the former Soviet Union, he says, there’s little political liberty. You can’t have one without the other.

So it’s vital that American students learn the facts about free enterprise. But do they?

A few textbooks at the high school and college undergraduate levels are good, says Burton Folsom Jr., a former college professor and now senior fellow at the Michigan- based Mackinac Center for Public Policy.

”The new high school textbooks are moving away from Keynes,” he said. ”But they’re still bad on antitrust, taxes and the Great Depression. They repeat myths about (John D.) Rockefeller and Reagan.”

Professor Richard Ebeling, head of the department of economics and business at Hillsdale College, agrees.

Some college texts now cite free-market economists such as Friedman and the monetarists or Hayek and the so-called Austrians, Ebeling says. But these schools of thought ”are explained in terms of a general Keynesian model or theory.”

”The Keynesian mind-set still dominates,” he said.

With that mind- set come many economic myths, false beliefs about markets and a skewed view of how the world works.

Folsom and his colleagues at the Mackinac Center are finishing a study of 16 high school textbooks. The books were reviewed to find whether students were getting a good economics education. So far, three books earned A’s, six got D’s, and two wound up with F’s.

Texts in their fifth or sixth editions still rely on Keynes, Folsom says. But the new texts are kinder to free enterprise.

”They’re good on trade issues and entrepreneurship – and there is some skepticism of big government,” Folsom said. However, they’re bad on antitrust, he says.

For instance, they repeat the myths about John D. Rockefeller and the robber barons, Folsom says.

”Rockefeller never had a monopoly. He had an oligopoly (a market controlled by a handful of firms),” Folsom said. ”The price of refined oil fell from 30 cents to 6 cents a gallon . . . (and) Standard Oil’s market share declined to 64% (in 1911 from 88% in 1890) because of competition – before the government broke it up.”

Standard’s share of oil production had dropped from 34% in 1890 to 11% in 1911 before antitrust enforcers broke this ”monopoly.”

Folsom also notes that U.S. Steel was the largest steel company in 1901; it held 61% of the market.

But because of competition, not antitrust laws, U.S. Steel’s market share fell to 39% by the mid-’20s.

”This is never mentioned in the textbooks,” Folsom said. The same holds true for American Sugar, he says, which held 98% of the market in the 1890s only to see its share decline due to competition.

A second myth, Folsom found, concerns taxes.

”Supply-side still hasn’t sunk in. Tax cuts in the ’20s produced more federal revenue, and cuts in the ’80s doubled federal revenue.” Only two texts were fair on this topic, Folsom says.

College texts still don’t treat supply-side economics right, Skousen says. ”It still gets a lot of criticism.”

A third myth is that laissez- faire capitalism caused the Great Depression and government spending cured it, say Folsom, Skousen and Ebeling.

”Almost every textbook misses on this,” Folsom said. ”Friedman proved that the Federal Reserve caused it, and government programs didn’t get us out of the Depression.”

Walter Williams, chairman of the economics department at George Mason University, agrees.

”Some textbooks say that runaway capitalism caused the Depression, when it was the Fed and the Smoot-Hawley tariff that did it,” Williams told IBD. ”Friedman confirmed this.”

Among economists, only those of the Austrian School, such as Hayek and Ludwig von Mises, clearly predicted the ’29 stock market crash and the Depression that followed.

They both blamed the Fed’s manipulation of the money supply, years before Friedman documented it. Yet the Austrian School rarely gets a mention in textbooks.

Williams adds that other related myths are that ”World War II brought us out of the Depression and that war is good for the economy.”

In fact, war means less money for real investment, he said, because money that could be going to factories and equipment is instead spent on troops and arms.

The minimum wage and the business cycle got fair treatment in about half the texts, Folsom said, but it’s still ”a mixed bag.”

Many texts still view the Fed as ”the savior” of the business cycle, he said, ”but we had more stability under the gold standard.”

There’s little debate among academic economists anymore that the minimum wage causes unemployment, Williams says. ”The debate is the magnitude.”

If money’s a problem, why not just make the minimum wage $25 an hour? Or $100? Obviously, supply and demand would intercede, and people would see the danger, Ebeling says.

Ditto for Fed control of the money supply. ”(Interest) rates are real. Why not make the rate zero? It’s like setting the price of shoes at zero.”

The myth that the minimum wage ”is a wonderful way of helping poor people,” however, is peddled by professors in other fields, said Donald Boudreaux, a former economics professor and now president of the Foundation for Economic Education.

”There is a knee-jerk reaction for government intervention at universities, even among those who’ve had economic training,” Boudreaux said. ”It’s a statist culture.”

Boudreaux adds that the problem with the textbooks began with Paul Samuelson. He’s a Keynesian and Nobel Prize winner whose books have dominated economics teaching since the ’40s.

Samuelson argues that economics is a science, Boudreaux says.

”He sees the economy as a machine that government can manipulate,” he said. ”The ideology is that if we get good people, we can master the economy.”

Ebeling adds that the myth is that ”the market is a planned mechanism” and planning is needed because markets fail.

This thinking pervades college textbooks, he says. It ignores the entrepreneur, who is the prime mover, and myriad complex and intricate relationships at the microeconomic level.

In some ways, the teaching of college economics has grown worse, Boudreaux says.

”By and large, the top schools, they teach technique, mathematical manipulation of economic models, a series of equations. They’re divorced from reality.”

But Skousen also sees a shift away from Keynes in newer college texts.

”All textbooks have shifted more toward free markets,” he said. They are going back to the classical, long-term growth model first and the Keynesian, short-term equilibrium model second. Friedman is cited more often, he said, and the Austrians get a little credit.

One of the biggest myths still peddled, however, is that the economy is consumer- driven, Skousen says.

”You see this all the time,” he said, ”references to retail sales, consumer spending. Consumption should be almost ignored. Focus on production. The economy is investment-driven.”

Filed Under: Articles, Economics, Free Markets

About Mark Skousen

Mark Skousen is a professional economist, university professor, best-selling author, editor of the award-winning Forecasts & Strategies financial newsletter, and producer of FreedomFest, the largest annual gathering of free minds about liberty and freedom in the world. Skousen has been married to wife Jo Ann for 42 years, and has five children and five grandchildren.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Connect with Mark Skousen

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Mark Skousen’s Top Ten

Top Ten

Recent Posts

Gross Output

Supply Chain Business Still Growing: Recession Fears May Not Pass GO

Washington, DC (Thursday, September 29, 2022): Today, the federal government … [Read More...]

Are economists the slowest learners?

Dear friends of freedom, Peter Drucker once said, "Economists are the slowest … [Read More...]

FreedomFest Agenda – Here’s a preview:

Dear friends of FreedomFest, The excitement is building for our July 13-16 … [Read More...]

Making of Modern Economics

Richard Rahn Reviews “The Making of Modern Economics” by Mark Skousen

Richard W. Rahn — economist, syndicated columnist and entrepreneur — reviewed … [Read More...]

Making of Modern Economics

“The Making of Modern Economics” – The book the New Socialists fear the most

Good news! The brand-new fourth edition of “The Making of Modern Economics” has … [Read More...]

Franklin

Why Ben Franklin Matters

Today is the 316th anniversary of the birth of founding father extraordinaire … [Read More...]

Economy

Economy Slows, But the Outlook is Still Positive

Washington, DC (Wednesday, December 22, 2021): Today, the federal government … [Read More...]

Samuelson vs Friedman, Match of the Century

By: Mark Skousen First published in the March 1999 issue of Liberty … [Read More...]

Gross Output

Despite Higher Inflation, the U.S. Economy Continues to Boom: Gross Output (GO) Hits $50 Trillion!

Washington, DC (Thursday, September 30, 2021): For the first time in history, … [Read More...]

Are we Rome?

Are We Rome?

By Mark Skousen Talk delivered on Saturday, September 11, 2021, Kimber … [Read More...]

Economy

While Inflation Threatens, the U.S. Economy is Firing on All Cylinders

  Washington, DC (Thursday, June 24, 2021): On June 24, 2021, the federal Bureau … [Read More...]

FreedomFest

Fun Things to Do at FreedomFest This July

We already have more than 2,000 registered attendees for FreedomFest next month. … [Read More...]

Walter Lippmann

Where’s Walter Lippmann when we need him?

Columnist and author Walter Lippmann (1889-1974) was considered the most … [Read More...]

Gross Output

Gross Output (GO) Growth Outpaces GDP Again to Suggest Robust Recovery

Washington, DC (Thursday, March 25, 2021): On March 25, 2021, the federal Bureau … [Read More...]

Gross Output

Business-to-Business (B2B) Spending Grows Faster Than GDP!

Washington, DC (Tuesday, December 22, 2020): On December 22, 2020, the federal … [Read More...]

Maxims

Ideal Holiday Gift! New 10th Anniversary Release of “The Maxims of Wall Street”

Dear friends, A hundred years ago, in 1920, the great author and poet Rudyard … [Read More...]

Ezra Taft Benson

Ezra Taft Benson’s Remarks at FEE Headquarters in New York, May 1977

In 2001-02, I served as president of the Foundation for Economic Education … [Read More...]

Ezra Taft Benson in Russia

Elder Ezra Taft Benson Speaks in Communist Russia

    “It was the most heart-rending and most inspiring scene … [Read More...]

lessons

10 LESSONS FOR 10-10-2020

This article was originally published on the FreedomFest Forum on October 10, … [Read More...]

GO-Day Celebration

Dear friends, Good news!  For the first time, the federal government (BEA) … [Read More...]

Gross Output

Macroeconomics on the GO: How Wall Street Economic Analysts Use Gross Output (GO)

Here are two examples of how private economic research firms are using gross … [Read More...]

Gross Output

Despite First Decline in More Than a Decade for Q1, Gross Output (GO) Might Still Offer Hope for a Robust Recovery in Late 2020

Washington, DC (Tuesday, July 7, 2020):  On July 6, 2020, the federal Bureau of … [Read More...]

FreedomFest

My Schedule at FreedomFest 2020

by Mark Skousen Editor, Forecasts & Strategies   Dear … [Read More...]

Forecasts & Strategies

40 Year of Forecasts & Strategies

Dear friends, My publisher, Salem Eagle, has just posted my special 40th … [Read More...]

GO

U.S. Economy on the GO: Total Spending Accelerates

Washington, DC (Thursday, January 9, 2020):  On January 9, 2020, the Bureau of … [Read More...]

MODERN MONETARY THEORY

THERE’S MUCH RUIN IN A NATION: MODERN MONETARY THEORY

By Mark Skousen Chapman University [email protected] “Today, as in the … [Read More...]

Forbes

Steve Forbes on the GO: I Make the Forbes 400 Richest Issue!

I’m mentioned on page 22 for my gross output (GO) model. (Sorry, I may be worth … [Read More...]

MY INTELLECTUAL ANCESTORS

BY MARK SKOUSEN Presidential Fellow, Chapman University "If I have seen a … [Read More...]

Trade

Trade War Threatens Recession

Washington, DC (Monday, July 29, 2019): On July 19, 2019, the federal … [Read More...]

FreedomFest

MY SCHEDULE AT FREEDOMFEST 2019

by Mark Skousen Editor, Forecasts & Strategies   Dear FreedomFest … [Read More...]

Austrian

AUSTRIAN VS. CHICAGO ECONOMISTS: RESPONSE TO THE 2008 FINANCIAL CRISIS

By Mark Skousen Updated in 2019  “Blessed paper credit! Last and best … [Read More...]

Gross Output

GO Confirms a Slow-Growth Economy as We Enter 2019

Washington, DC (Friday, April 19, 2019): Today the federal government released … [Read More...]

Gross Output

The US Economy is NOT Slowing Down. Business Spending Soars!

By Mark Skousen Editor, Forecasts & Strategies Washington, DC (Thursday, … [Read More...]

Making of Modern Economics

The Economist Publishes New Ad for “Making of Modern Economics”

The November 24th issue of The Economist, page 73, is running a new full-page … [Read More...]

Gross Output

Gross Output Indicates Continued Boom in the U.S. Economy as Business Spending Expands Rapidly in Q2

Washington, DC (Thursday, November 1, 2018):  Gross output (GO), the top line of … [Read More...]

Adam Smith

ADAM SMITH AND THE MAKING OF MODERN ECONOMICS

By Mark Skousen Presidential Fellow, Chapman … [Read More...]

Gross output

US Economy Continues to Expand, but Business Spending Slows Temporarily

Washington, DC (Friday, July 20, 2018):  Gross output (GO), the top line of … [Read More...]

Steve Forbes

Full Remarks by Steve Forbes On the Presentation of a Triple Crown in Economics to Mark Skousen

The following are Mr. Forbes remarks following Skousen’s session on “Adam Smith, … [Read More...]

Steve Forbes

STEVE FORBES AWARDS MARK SKOUSEN A TRIPLE CROWN IN ECONOMICS

For Immediate Release July 18, 2018 Washington, DC:  Steve Forbes, chairman … [Read More...]

Mark Skousen’s article on Revista Procesos de Mercado (Review of Market Processes)

Revista Procesos de Mercado (Review of Market Processes) has just published Mark … [Read More...]

If GDP Lags, Watch the Economy GO

‘Gross output’ reflects the full value of the supply chain, and it portends much … [Read More...]

Away We GO: Business Spending Accelerates in 4th quarter 2017

Washington, DC (Thursday, April 19, 2018) Gross output (GO), the top line of … [Read More...]

GO

GO Slow: New Leading Indicator Predicted Slowdown in GDP

by Mark Skousen Presidential Fellow, Chapman University Editor, Forecasts … [Read More...]

gross output

THIRD QUARTER GROSS OUTPUT AND B2B SPENDING GAIN MOMENTUM

Washington, DC (Friday, January 19, 2018): Gross output (GO), the top line of … [Read More...]

2ND QUARTER GROSS OUTPUT SHOWS SURPRISE SLOWDOWN IN ECONOMY

Washington, DC (Thursday, November 2, 2017): Gross output (GO), the top line of … [Read More...]

Economic Logic

ANNOUNCING A NEW EDITION BREAKTHROUGH COURSE IN FREE-MARKET CAPITALISM

“Mark Skousen is America’s leading economic author because he roots his luminous … [Read More...]

Gross Output

RAPID GROWTH IN 1ST QUARTER GO: ECONOMY IS NOT SLOWING DOWN

By: MARK SKOUSEN Washington, DC (Wednesday, July 26, 2017): Gross output … [Read More...]

GROSS OUTPUT AND B2B INDEX ADVANCE SHARPLY AFTER ELECTION

Washington, DC (Friday, April 21, 2017): Gross output (GO), the top line of … [Read More...]

SECOND QUARTER GROSS OUTPUT AND B2B INDEX INCREASE, STILL NO SIGNIFICANT GROWTH OF THE U.S. ECONOMY.

By Mark Skousen Washington, DC (Thursday, November 3, 2016):  Gross output, … [Read More...]

FIRST QUARTER GROSS OUTPUT AND B2B INDEX POINT TO NEGLIGIBLE GROWTH OF THE U.S. ECONOMY

Washington, DC (Thursday, July 21, 2016):  U. S. economic activity is still … [Read More...]

HOW BEN FRANKLIN SAVED THE POST OFFICE AND HELPED UNIFY AMERICA

By Mark Skousen Special to the Franklin Prosperity Report July 4, … [Read More...]

FreedomFest Fun Activities

In addition to all the great debates, presentation and hundreds of vendors in … [Read More...]

Big news: the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) has changed its definition of GDP that starts with Gross Output.

This is a significant breakthrough, which I have encouraged them to do for some … [Read More...]

FOURTH QUARTER GROSS OUTPUT AND B2B INDEX POINT TO BUSINESS RECESSION

By Mark Skousen April 21, 2016 Washington, DC (Thursday, April 21, 2016):  … [Read More...]

CATO INSTITUTE POLICY FORUM: “GO Beyond GDP: What Really Drives the Economy?”

We hear constantly that consumer spending is 70% of GDP and that consumer … [Read More...]

ANNOUNCING THE NEW THIRD EDITION OF “THE MAKING OF MODERN ECONOMICS” BY MARK SKOUSEN

March 9, 2016: Today marks the 240th anniversary of the publication of “The … [Read More...]

Announcing the New Third Edition of “The Structure of Production”

Federal Government Introduces a New Macro Statistic: A Triumph in Supply-side … [Read More...]

My Friendly Fights with Dr. Friedman

The Rational, The Relentless - Liberty Magazine - September 2007 by Mark … [Read More...]

The Making of Modern Economics

Recent Comments

  • Missy on Gary North, R. I. P.
  • Valerie on 10 LESSONS FOR 10-10-2020
  • Arch G. Woodside on The Other Austrian
  • Troy Lynch on Gary North, R. I. P.
  • Wayne Flanagan on Ideal Holiday Gift! New 10th Anniversary Release of “The Maxims of Wall Street”

Contact Mark Skousen

Personal Email

Forecasts & Strategies Email

FreedomFest Email

Social Media:
Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter

Websites:
mskousen.com
markskousen.com
freedomfest.com

Mark Skousen Newsletters

 Mark Skousen Investment Newsletters

Since 1980, Skousen has been editor in chief of Forecasts & Strategies, a popular award-winning investment newsletter. He also is editor of three trading services, Skousen Private Equity Trader; Skousen High-Income Alert and Fast Money Alert.

Jo Ann Skousen’s Odds & Trends

Jo Ann Skousen

Movie reviews, theater reviews, and commentaries by Jo Ann Skousen, author, editor, professor and Mark's wife of 41 years. She is the Festival Director for the Anthem Libertarian Film Festival and the entertainment editor for Liberty Magazine.

Mark Skousen’s Investor’s CAFE

Mark Skousen Investors CAFE

Skousen Investor CAFÉ is a weekly electronic newsletter written by Dr. Mark Skousen. Mark offers commentary on the markets, the economy, politics and other topics of interest and what they mean to individual investors. Sign up for FREE here.

FreedomFest Conference


FreedomFest is an annual festival in Las Vegas where free minds meet to celebrate “great books, great ideas, and great thinkers” in an open-minded society. It is independent, non-partisan, and not affiliated with any organization or think tank.

Anthem Film Festival

Anthem Libertarian Film Festival

Anthem is the only film festival in the country devoted to promoting libertarian ideals. Anthem shows films and documentaries that celebrate self-reliance, innovation, commerce, individual rights, and the power of persuasion over force. We are looking for the year's best films about personal and civil liberty.

Copyright © 2023 · Mark Skousen · Log in

✖

Cancel reply

Cancel